The 47 is a Glock 17 MOS slide on a Glock 45 frame, so it's not supremely unique by any stretch. Would recommend . For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. Glock rolled out the Gen 3 in 1998, an upgrade to its second generation of pistols. Replaced the 336 ejectors with the 30274 type and the problem went away. The Gen 5 finished its design off with a flared magwell, aiding shooters with tactical reloads and the like. Its time to see if the 47021 ejector, which is currently shipping with the G26 gen 5 and G34 gen 5, and the 19X, is as good as the 336, 3027) or 47021 ejectors. It affected Gen 3 and 4 pistols. Regarding the comparison between the 80P, Suarez, and Swenson, were all other parts original? I had originally purchased a Gen 3 19 that had really, really bad BTF and ejection out of the box - sometimes it would drill me between the eyes, sometimes the brass would drop on the webbing of my hand behind the gun, you name it. 3. The 17M has Gen 5 features with a Gen 4 slide, frame and internals, including the omitted finger grooves, a flared magwell and the Glock Marksman Barrel. And/or replace the ejector with Glock . A lot of people consider a Gen 3 as a starting point. It is. I bought the shapeshift for my Glock 17 (gen 4). Some OEM and aftermarket parts fit all Glock generations, others do not. As luck would have it, right after I bought my G19, reports started surfacing about problems with 3rd Gen guns, too, and my G19 exhibited horrific ejection issues. Please enable Javascript and refresh the page for a safe, secure, and complete shopping experience at Midwest Gun Works. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Reply. Tiffany Blue, FDE and olive drab were offered on select models as additional colors. A version that did not use an ambidextrous release was made available. All gen 4-5 now and no btf with those. Create an Account; Login; Create an Account; Cart (0) View Cart; Checkout; Brownells Brownells 75th Anniversary - A Shooting Heritage. Gaston Glock ushered in the modern era of polymer framed pistols. Copyright 1996-2023 AR15.COM LLC. The Slimline models have features of multiple Glock generations. Budget Lever-Action Shotgun: Reviewing GForces LVR410. Glocks have always had the issue. Our site uses JavaScript for a smooth and modern shopping experience; we protect your data and never sell it to 3rd parties. So, if you're wondering what the differences are between, say, a Gen 3 vs Gen 5 Glock, we're going to explain the difference. By the end, you should have a better understanding of which Glock extractor will work best for you. A great middle man between the past and the present, the Gen 4 is a great mesh between the Gen 3 and Gen 5. For those with bigger hands or smaller ones, the finger grooves prove to be annoying to work around. .45 ACP rounds typically deliver somewhere around 350 to 500 foot/pounds of kinetic energy; the 10mm typically starts at around 530 ft/lbs . From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. The dual-spring Gen 4 Gen 4 captive spring is the most noticeable difference between these two models (the single-spring Gen 3 from G3). Additional calibers, including .357 Sig and .45 GAP or Glock Auto Pistol, a .45-caliber cartridge with roughly the same case length as 9mm to fit the larger projectile in a 9mm frame. The Gen 5, though, does come with a new DLC coating that looks nice but accumulates finger prints. I snagged three generations of Glock 19 pistols from the Guns.com warehouse the Gen 3, Gen 4 and Gen 5 to evaluate the similarities and differences among these series. When the Gen 4s were built the Gen 3s got the same locking block but there was a slight change in the height of the locking blocks. It will nicely pile the cases to my right no matter what I shoot through it now. The Apex Failure Resistant Extractor for Glock pistols is designed with a more robust extractor claw and utilizes Apex's proprietary geometry. Its not a wow factor and in fact most shooters will likely not notice a difference in shootability between the Gen 4 and Gen 5 platforms. This makes it possible to customize the gun to your specific needs and preferences. Apex: Black color. Must use new style spring loaded bearing with this extractor. These are the rarest of all Glock pistols and oddly enough command something of a premium on the used market. A lot of the problem is the machining of the slide. G37 must use new style spring loaded New style Loaded Chamber Indicator allows you to verify your pistol is loaded or not with a simple glance. In this article, well dive into the differences between the various Glock extractors and explore which one is best for your needs. A word of warning though. I also ran some rounds through my G43 and guess what, it was perfect. Glock had made much ado about their polygonal rifling, a rifling pattern that few other gun companies employ. Notes Only for use in the Generation 3 Glock pistols. This product isnt in high demand these days. Has anybody ever tried using a non-LCI spring bearing with a LCI extractor? Same as the above posterI even had some brass eject forward and to the left. Need Help? G36 only with non-LCI extractor. On some of my Glocks it was really bad; one day after shooting the worst G19 I came home with five bruises on my forehead and my wife was like WTF. When I was experiencing this issue several years ago, I found a couple of threads that were especially helpful, one of which was this thread: *Must have a registered ARFCOM account to win. I do not want that in addition to the new mag release. The standard ejector is used in most Glock pistols, while the small and large frame ejectors are used in some of the larger models. In the broad strokes, the Gen 5 guns are going to be "better" in many regards if you were weighing a Glock Gen 3 vs Gen 5 pistol. Ejection is perfect except on the last round, then it is weak and erratic. A compensated version - the 18C - was also devised. Thank you for the information. However, if you hate your fingers being forced into a set position, the Gen 4 might be more of a headache. It should be the same parts that you would use to rebuild a pistol magazine in your early 20s. The extractor is a band-aid fix. glock 17 gen 3 (older one with beter materials). well thanks. No longer have that gun though. The versatility of the Gen 3 has been a major factor in its success, as it is one of the most versatile Glock models available. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. Powered by Invision Community. Before I read the ejector threadI thought that was just the way Glocks ejected their brass. Make sure you tell guys that the 1911 is a pain in the ass - Larry Vickers. The frame texturing is revised, and the Gen 5 guns also come with swappable backstraps and a slightly flared magwell. By the end of this article, you should have a good idea of what it means when you see "Glock Gen Whatever" and understand what it means, especially if you were thinking of buying a Glock pistolwhich is always a good call. Glocks Generation 3 guns are still armed with the 336 ejector. The 43 is a single stack but the 43x and 48 are different. AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own. That being said, each features their own unique attributes that may speak to gun owners more so than the other. but it was changed to Glock's standard black finish in the fullness of time. Just thinking out loud A forum community dedicated to Glock firearm owners and enthusiasts. This was a good read but, not even mentioned, Glock 18, I know, I know, this is a handgun capital of being fired "FULL AUTO". Good points, I really like the 40 to 9 conv so it will mostly be shot this way in 3 gun matches. It's also the case that some guns - such as the Glock 40 in 10mm or Glock 41 in .45 ACP - are only optic-ready in Gen 4 trim. Like anything else, incremental changes are made to the Glock platform to make it ostensibly better; and they usually are. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. Glock pistols have polymer receivers with molded-in steel slide rails. I bought a new 17L in 09 that had bad ejection it would regularly stovepipe. As indicated in the product descriptions, none of the parts and accessories on this site are official Glock products.Item # SP01176 (available at Brownells.com, MidwayUSA.com or sharpsshootingsupply.com).And/or replace the ejector with Glock Glock is a federally registered trademark of Glock, Inc. and is one of many trademarks owned by Glock, Inc. or Glock Ges.m.b.H. BrianEnos.com Since you are only having problems when using certain types of ammo (range and target types), you are just making more issue and work for yourself than necessary. Extractor 10mm G20 - G29 non-LCI for older slide with 90 degree ejection port. I have a gen 5. Can I put a Gen4 22 Advantage Arms 22LR conversion upper on my P80 19Glock version? The Glock generations are the ongoing changes made to the design of the Glock pistol. Decrease Quantity of Glock OEM EXTRACTOR DEPRESSOR PLUNGER ASSEMBLY G42 380 Increase Quantity of Glock OEM EXTRACTOR DEPRESSOR PLUNGER ASSEMBLY G42 380. Is there a place to view inter generation changes/upgrades? Gen 3 parts are ridiculously common; Gen 4 and Gen 5 OEM parts are a little less common and a little more expensive. The Glock 24 - a longslide model in .40 S&W - was also released for competition shooters looking to make Major Power Factor, which cycled in and out of the product lineup. Did I read this correctly? ), but there is no link between generation and production. If you want the best out of them, you have to invest some time and money into improving it. See our Policies page for full details here, 60-day return policy + Limited lifetime warranty. Cured with Apex extractor. JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser. The grip texture remained the same, but the design benefits from an ambi slide stop again, catering to left-handed shooters. This also applies to aftermarket parts like triggers, sights, magazine wells, magazines themselves, and so on. In a lot of respects, it's not; it doesn't make for fun trivia and remembering where you put your car keys is much more important. Glock Extractor Depressor Plunger. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. Posted April 23, 2012. Change ammo, or Leave the guns stock, and just wear a brimmed hat with eye pro. The big-bore Glocks are Gen 3 or Gen 4. This not only demonstrates the durability of the Gen 3, but it also demonstrates that parts for the Gen 3 can be used with parts for the Gen 5. April 23, 2012 in Glock. Like the Gen 5 models, the 48 and 43X are both offered in MOS (Modular Optic System) configuration, with a milled slide for mounting an optic. How much different/longer is a Glock 17/9mm extractor from a Glock35/40 extractor. Born in southeastern Washington State, Sam Hoober graduated in 2011 from Eastern Washington University. I figured I'd try this for fun with a Gen 4 19 that has periodic BTF with lower powered cheap ammo. The original Glock 17 sold pretty well to police departments, militaries and to early-adopting civilians. Out of curiosity, I picked up billet extractors from 80P builder and from Midway USA (branded "Swenson") (both are linked in my opening post). I have a 17/5 and 19/5 the new 19 was weak and put empty's here and there, I put the 47021 eject in and its way way better . Great write up, love my gen 1 & 2 but going to be putting a gen 5 through it's paces shortly. 5 Best for Any Budget [2022]. Placing a preorder allows you to "get in line" and reserve your product: the quickest way to acquire an out of stock item. It seems as long as there is a round in the magazine, all is well. The spent case cannot be removed by hand if the extractor hooks are worn down. Part number 3 on the Glock Schematic. usmc1974 Disclaimer | Privacy Policy. Since its introduction in 1988 as part of the Generation 3 series, the Glock 19 has been a runaway hit. JavaScript is not enabled on your browser - our site will not work for you as intended. (Photo: Jacki Billings/Guns.com). Many Glock 19 holsters, for instance, will fit all generations; some will only fit up to Gen 3. Better to have and not need than need and not have. Some guns sent with BTF to Glock return with the 30274 ejector installed. However, the 17M and 19M were never (and aren't going to be) offered for civilian sale. Not tested to work with any caliber except for 9mm. Heavier and with a clunkier feel while shooting, the Gen 3 can be a surprise for shooters accustomed to later model Glocks. Recoil springs are not interchangeable between the third and fourth generation with an adapter. But what many people dont know is that not all Glock extractors are the same. The assembly comes with the trigger return spring which is nice. Regardless of generation, each Glock is a solid build delivering accuracy and reliability. (VIDEO). Glock Extractor 9mm & .380 Auto (15) w/ Loaded Chamber Indicator, Glock Extractor .380 Auto Slim (15-5) w/ Loaded Chamber Indicator (G42), Glock Extractor 9mm Slim (15-0) w/ Loaded Chamber Indicator (G43, G43X, G48), Glock Extractor Training (15) w/ Loaded Chamber Indicator (G17T), Glock Extractor 9mm (90) for Old Style Non-LCI Slides w/ 90 Ejection Port, Glock Extractor .40 S&W & .357 SIG (15-5) w/ Loaded Chamber Indicator, Glock Extractor .40 S&W (90-5) for Old Style Non-LCI Slides w/ 90 Ejection Port, Glock Extractor 10mm (15-5) w/ Loaded Chamber Indicator (G20, G29), Glock Extractor 10mm (15-5) for Non-LCI Slides w/ 15 Ejection Port (G20, G29), Glock Extractor 10mm (90-5) for Non-LCI Slides w/ 90 Ejection Port (G20, G29), Glock Extractor .45 ACP & .45 GAP (15-5) w/ LCI (G21, G21SF, G30, G37, G37 Gen4, G38, G39), Glock Extractor .45 ACP (15-5) w/ Loaded Chamber Indicator (G30S, G36, G36FGR, G41 Gen4), Glock Extractor .45 Auto Non-LCI, G36 Only, Apex Failure Resistant Extractor for Glock Pistols, Gen 3 / 5, Apex Failure Resistant Extractor Kit for Glock Pistols, Gen 4, Glock Extractor 9mm (G17 Gen5, G19 Gen5, G19X, G26 Gen5, G34 Gen5 MOS, G45, G45 MOS), 1101 Mason Circle Drive Pevely, MO 63070 Mon-Fri 8:00am - 4:00pm CST, 2023 Midwest Gun Works, Inc. - All Rights Reserved, Extractor Depressor Plunger and Spring Assembly. I saw in an email the other day that Lone Wolf now has a stainless extractor available. No markings on extractors. Lucky for you, Alien Gear makes holsters right here in the USA that fit all Glock generations. I'm torn on trying a different extractor, but not sure which is more preferred? Perfect for that gun owner who has to have the latest and greatest, the Gen 5 saw the return of a straight grip, no finger grooves, in addition to kicking up some internal features that smooth out the overall operation. Thanks for the article. New style Loaded Chamber Indicator allows you to verify your pistol is loaded or not with a simple glance. Copyright 1996-2023 AR15.COM LLC. When did they stop making gen3. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. Interesting to read about the barrel - good insight regarding competition use (or lack thereof). Many Gen 5 guns can be had with the Glock MOS slide cuts for mounting an optic. The ejector on the trigger housing pretty much determines which way the empty goes. I also fired a box of Tula brass cased ammo that I had bought from Wal Mart a few years ago in my BBHB serial number prefix G17, and ejection was all over the place! Taurus Defender 856 TORO Brings Optic-Ready Performance to a Revolver. The type of ejector used can affect the performance and reliability of the weapon, so it is important to know which one is best for the pistol in question. So far, they are restricted to 9mm and .40 S&W. Which is Better? Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by WordPress. Thanks for doing the testing (and thanks to the guy bumping the thread). Originally, the Slimline models were offered with a silver NVD finish on the slide (seen above!) Ask any lefty; there is a HUGE difference between gen 3 and gen 4. Menu. It works great in mine for any 9mm I've shot. I have a G19 that has never had an issue. The gun includes the Glock Marksman Barrel and omits finger grooves (Gen 5 features) but otherwise has a Gen 3 slide, frame and small parts, and is wrapped up with an FDE finish. Part number 3 on the Glock Schematic. While the Gen 4 guns were initially marketed as the replacement for the Gen 3 guns, but that has changed. There are differences as a result of production changes (such as G19 VAR1 barrels, LCI Extractors, locking block pins, etc. $7.99. MGW carries a vast array of replacement barrels, slides, sights, magazines, triggers, pins, springs and more for this iconic handgun. One new winner* is announced every week! This replacement part is a factory original from Glock. The second generation of Glock pistols started with a number of minor design changes as well as the addition of the Glock 19 to the model lineup in 1988. Wed be remiss if we didnt start by saying you cant go wrong with Glock. The Gen 4 and 5 ejectors will work in Gen 3s. (Photo: Jacki Billings/Guns.com), The dual recoil spring of the newer gens, right, is a vast improvement over the Gen 3s single recoil spring. No, not all Glock ejectors are the same. For 9mm 336 is Gen3, 30274 is Gen4/5, the best ejector is the 47201 which comes in the 19x trigger housing part# 47208. Sounds like either weak ammo or a grip issue. GLOCK G19 Gen 4 vs G19 Gen 5 Handgun (gen 4 not to scale, lol) The Gen 5 Glocks ship with Ameriglo GLOCK Spartan Operator night sights up from polymer sights. I'm calling Smyrna in the morning for another return label and I'll let them try again. The 19X was Glock's failed bid for the US military's XM17 handgun trials, but was put on sale with some success. The 47021 displayed exceptional performance, throwing brass strongly at 3, 3:30, 10 feet away. A word of warning though. We use cookies to give you the best possible user experience & to analyze traffic. The rim diameter on a 9mm is .392" and the 40S&W is .424", but the machined recess is the same diameter for both at .346". Just bought a used Gen 3 G17 built in the same time-frame that was virtually brand new. Might need to respring it. Add to Cart Compare. In this article, we'll dive into the differences between the various Glock extractors and explore which one is best for your needs. Still had the factory gold grease on the slide. The Glock 43X and Glock 48 pistols use essentially the same frame as a Glock 43, albeit with a longer grip housing for the Slimline magazine. Gen 1 19s made their way to the Kansas Alcohol and Beverage Control Agency sometime early 1988 as the barrel codes date to December 1987(ATY). Other plates may also be used to add accessories such as optics, lights, or lasers. The use of Glock on this page is merely to advertise the sale of Glock parts or components. The biggest difference between the extractors is that the 40 extractor has a 5-degree bevel on the front to reduce stress on the lower part of the hook during feeding.. Its not the first Glock Ive had that had a piss-poor RSA by design. So ultimately it's whether the features of each generation are worth it to you, and that's something only you can answer. 1902 wLCI - this is for standard width slides and should be what all of your Glock extractors are. For .40/.357 1882 is Gen3, Gen4 .40 is 28926 and .357 has its own Gen4 ejector. The frame and slide were also beefed up, typically increasing slide and frame width by 0.1 inches. Glock couldnt fix it and neither could I as the aftermarket parts to fix it werent available yet. Ratings Snapshot 5. out of 5. I started out with Glocks with an ancient 2nd Gen G21 (serial number AVExxx, so basically right after Glock introduced them). The Glock 19 Gen 4 upgrades are subtle, yet leap out at the same time. If you have any questions related to the pricing and/or discount offered in a particular listing, please contact the seller for that listing. Skip to the beginning of the images gallery. For instance, the Ford Mustang is broadly the same size today as it was in 1963 and it's still a front-engine/rear-wheel-drive carbut today's Mustang is a lot different! Apex is an independent manufacturer and seller of aftermarket parts and accessories for Glock pistols, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Glock, Inc. or Glock Ges.m.b.H. Good article but you didnt mention the larger magazine release button starting with gen 4 which also could be switched to the right side for lefty shooters. You should try the OEM. Get Guns.com offers and news!! The Gen 4, launched in 2010, further improving on the Glock design. just ordered the trigger housing for the 5th gen and for $7 i don't see why not. . Powered by BigCommerce. Not sure which ejector is in it either. The Gen 3 continued its upgrades with a universal accessory rail for mounting lights and laser accessories. The versatility of the interchangeable parts also allows you to easily switch out parts in the event that something breaks or needs to be replaced. the new 17/5 has the 30274 and it worked good from day one , maybe because its slide has more mass ???? The 43X slide and barrel are the same as the 43, just on a longer frame. Anyone have any suggestions of where to look? Unfortunately the problem is not with the ejector. [2022], Sig P320 Vs Glock 19. have yet to shoot any of my glocks but still picked up a 47021 for each of them just in case i need them. service@guns.com Apex is an independent manufacturer and seller of aftermarket parts and accessories for Glock pistols, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Glock, Inc. or Glock Ges.m.b.H. MAJ Kelly. Understanding Ammo Choices For The Glock 19: Pros And Cons Of Short Barrel And Regular Ammo, Accuracy And Precision With The Glock New York Trigger, Loading Your Glock 44: A Step-by-Step Guide To Safely And Effectively Load Your Magazine. That COULD be a problem, but it would likely work more often than not. How is that even possible? When installed, the extractor will: Model 17, 19, 26 and 34 with Glock Item # SP01176 (available at Brownells.com, MidwayUSA.com or sharpsshootingsupply.com). Author. This means that a wide variety of parts and accessories can be used to customize a Glock to suit an individuals preferences. However to this day, Glock still ships gen 3 guns with the 336 ejector, despite the fact that some gen 3 guns that get sent to Glock with BTF issues come back with the 30274 ejector installed. Regardless, Glock slide plates are an easy and cost-effective way to customize your firearm. Prior to that all the practice ammo I have ever fired in that gun has been aluminum cased ammo. Extractor Spring. The 19x ejector has worked great. The venerable Glock is synonymous with reliability and ruggedness, proving itself over the years as a worthy contender in the self-defense and personal protection realms. I thought the Suarez extractor color might bother me a little, but I think it looks pretty good now. Both of the G30sfs have had the issue since day one. Extractor 45 Auto. 40 ejector. As a result, Glock owners should keep an eye out for their ejections and replace them if they become too worn down. Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy. Thanks for your thoughts. Been trying to find the trigger housing with the 47021 ejector in it all day without having any success. Besides the swappable backstrap panels, there are few differences between the Gen 3 vs Gen 4 Glock pistols that really add up to much worth talking about. Well also examine why having the right extractor is important and how it can affect the performance of your gun. Its perfectly acceptable; Ive seen results like mine multiple times with Apex extractor, and Im certain thats nothing to be concerned about. The first difference between Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4 that many sees are the grips. This past weekend I put my oem extractor back in my G34.4 but kept the gen 5 ejector in. Some folks had to resort to the expensive Apex aftermarket extractor to get their guns to run right. Finally we have the 47021 ejector. .40 slide is heavier. As a result, their Glock pistols will continue to be dependable and accurate.